What Claude (Anthropic) with web search answered for payroll software (freelancers) on 2026-09-20

Claude (Anthropic) with web search claude-opus-5 asked 2026-09-20

Coverage: Claude (Anthropic) with web search. Other engines not included.

The question asked, verbatim: best payroll software for freelancers

Brands named, in the order the engine gave

1. S-corp mentioned
   Payroll only becomes necessary if you've elected S-corp status (you must pay yourself a "reasonable salary" via W-2) or you're paying other people.
2. Gusto recommended
   Gusto - the default recommendation.
3. Gusto Solo mentioned
   They have a Gusto Solo tier built specifically for one-person S-corps, including a reasonable-salary calculator to help you pick a compliant number.
4. OnPay mentioned
   OnPay - flat $49/mo + $6 per person, unlimited payroll runs, all 50 states included.
5. Collective mentioned
   Collective - not software exactly;
6. Wave mentioned
   Wave or Gusto's contractor-only plan - Gusto charges ~$6/contractor/month with no base fee, files the 1099-NECs, and you skip the payroll subscription entirely.
7. QuickBooks mentioned
   If you're a sole prop and what you actually want is tax/expense tracking: QuickBooks Solopreneur (the successor to QuickBooks Self-Employed, which was discontinued) or FreshBooks - mileage, expenses, quarterly estimate projections.
8. QuickBooks Solopreneur mentioned
   If you're a sole prop and what you actually want is tax/expense tracking: QuickBooks Solopreneur (the successor to QuickBooks Self-Employed, which was discontinued) or FreshBooks - mileage, expenses, quarterly estimate projections.
9. QuickBooks Self-Employed mentioned
   If you're a sole prop and what you actually want is tax/expense tracking: QuickBooks Solopreneur (the successor to QuickBooks Self-Employed, which was discontinued) or FreshBooks - mileage, expenses, quarterly estimate projections.
10. FreshBooks mentioned
    If you're a sole prop and what you actually want is tax/expense tracking: QuickBooks Solopreneur (the successor to QuickBooks Self-Employed, which was discontinued) or FreshBooks - mileage, expenses, quarterly estimate projections.

Sources the engine cited

The answer, as recorded

**First, the honest caveat:** if you're a sole proprietor or single-member LLC, you don't need payroll software at all. You can't put yourself on payroll - you take owner's draws and pay quarterly estimated taxes. Payroll only becomes necessary if you've elected S-corp status (you must pay yourself a "reasonable salary" via W-2) or you're paying other people. So here's what I'd actually name, by case: **If you're an S-corp (the main reason a freelancer needs payroll):** 1. **Gusto** - the default recommendation. They have a **Gusto Solo** tier built specifically for one-person S-corps, including a reasonable-salary calculator to help you pick a compliant number. Automated federal/state/local filing, and it handles contractor payments and 1099-NECs on the same account if you ever subcontract. 2. **OnPay** - flat $49/mo + $6 per person, unlimited payroll runs, all 50 states included. Cleaner pricing than Gusto if you want one predictable number, and they market directly to S-corp solopreneurs. 3. **Patriot Software** - the budget pick. Basic full-service payroll for roughly $17-37/mo. Fewer frills, but if all you're doing is running the same salary twice a month, you're paying for filing accuracy, not features. 4. **Collective** - not software exactly; it's a bundled service (S-corp formation + bookkeeping + payroll + tax filing) for solopreneurs. Costs several hundred a month, but if you elected S-corp and don't want to think about compliance at all, this is the "hand it to someone" option. **If you're just paying subcontractors (not yourself):** 5. **Wave** or **Gusto's contractor-only plan** - Gusto charges ~$6/contractor/month with no base fee, files the 1099-NECs, and you skip the payroll subscription entirely. Wave is worth a look if you already invoice through it. **If you're a sole prop and what you actually want is tax/expense tracking:** QuickBooks Solopreneur (the successor to QuickBooks Self-Employed, which was discontinued) or FreshBooks - mileage, expenses, quarterly estimate projections. That's the real need most freelancers have when they go searching for "payroll." **My pick:** Gusto if you're an S-corp, Gusto's contractor-only plan if you're paying freelancers, and neither if you're a sole prop. One thing worth checking before you commit: if the S-corp election itself is the open question, run the numbers first - the payroll cost plus bookkeeping typically only pays off above roughly $80-100k in net profit, so the software choice is downstream of that decision. Sources: - [Gusto Solo: Payroll for Solopreneurs & One-Person S Corps](https://gusto.com/product/solutions/size/solo) - [S Corp Payroll Services Built for Solopreneurs | OnPay](https://onpay.com/payroll/software/industries/s-corp-payroll/) - [Payroll Solutions for Solopreneurs: A Comparison Guide | Collective](https://www.collective.com/blog/money-management/payroll-solutions-for-solopreneurs-a-comparison-guide) - [S Corp Payroll Guide: Setting Up and Managing Payroll | Collective](https://www.collective.com/blog/money-management/scorp-payroll) - [How to Manage Payroll for Self-Employed Professionals](https://www.selfemployed.com/payroll-options-for-self-employed-business-owners/) - [6 Best Affordable Payroll Software for Self-Employed](https://www.selfemployed.com/affordable-payroll-software-2026/) - [Self-Employed & Sole Proprietor Business Services | Paychex](https://www.paychex.com/business-solutions/self-employed)

Markdown edition · the question page, with every recording · Answer Watch · AEO Watch

Answer Watch records what one AI answer engine said on one date, nothing more. Each page names the engine and the model, carries the date the question was asked, and lists the brands that appeared in the answer in the order the engine gave them, with the sources it cited. It is a measurement, not a ranking, not a recommendation and not a claim about the world. Brands that did not appear in an answer are not named on any public page. Coverage: Claude (Anthropic) with web search. Other engines not included.